We don’t rank flavors by committee. We rank them by the order data: what customers buy first, what they reorder, and what they send as gifts. Here’s the current lineup, 10 flavors, ranked by real demand.
The ranking
- Green Apple — the #1 seller, period. Crisp, real, and the flavor most first-timers say matches the experience. The full review covers why.
- Strawberry — the gifting classic; the flavor people buy for someone else without asking.
- Pineapple — the road trip flavor; tangy, tropical, and the beach-day default.
- Juicy Peach (Motel Magic) — the best-selling full-strength flavor, by a wide margin.
- Watermelon — summer in a pouch; the flavor that spikes hardest in June–August orders.
- Black Cherry (Motel Magic) — the connoisseur’s pick; deep, dark, boozy.
- Blue Raspberry — the nostalgia engine; fairgrounds flavor with a real following.
- Rocket Pop — the festival flavor; three layers of berry in one gummy.
- Sunset Punch — the golden-hour flavor; mango-pineapple-guava, our most tropical.
- Cotton Candy — the first-timer’s pick; the sweetest entry point in the line.
How to read the ranking
Positions 1–3 are safe defaults — for you or for a gift. Positions 4–7 are where regulars start their rotations. Positions 8–10 are the personality picks, and they’re the ones that turn into someone’s forever flavor. The chocolate line runs a separate ranking — Cookies & Cream leads there too, and the four-bar tasting breaks it down.
Not sure which to try first?
The sample bundle ($9.99, two 2-count tasters) is the honest answer: let your palate rank, not ours. Every flavor is in the mushroom gummies collection, full-strength options in Motel Magic, and the FAQ answers the dosing questions each flavor raises.